original live version of Dogs?

aski · 01-28-2011, 09:15 PM

hi!

does anyone have the 'original live version' of Dogs from way back before 9 was released?

according to the user "mestonf", he really favoured this version instead of the studio version:

"All of them are bloody awesome. Though, in comparison to the original live version of 'the girl who does yoga,' I think the studio version is less intensive. What made the live version was his fast guitar strumming. It just doesn't seem to have the same effect on me.
Nevertheless, it's just amazing.................absolutely love it!"

the user "mestonf" hasn't been online at the forum since 2009, so i guess it would be pointless to ask him about this version.

anyone who knows which show this first version appeared at?

verenita · 01-29-2011, 12:16 AM

i´m a bit lost... i don´t know what "original" live version is, but i´m sure some eskimos mye help you (or even meself if i get an answer

).

aski · 01-29-2011, 05:57 AM

i checked out all the set lists at ninecrimes.it, and at these shows Dogs was played, then titled "The Girl Who Does Yoga":

21/02/2003 - Hop & Grape, Manchester, Inghilterra

Setlist
01. The professor
02. Volcano
03. Delicate
04. Lazy situation
05. I remember
06. Amie
07. Woman like a man
08. The girl that does yoga
09. Silent night
10. The blower's daughter >
11. Creep
12. Sand
13. Older chests
14. Cannonball
15. Be my husband
16. Childish
17. Cold water >
18. Hallelujah
19. Eskimo

03/05/2003 - Fez Under Time, New York, USA

Setlist
1. Cannonball
2. I Remember
3. Face
4. Prague
5. Older Chests
6. Delicate
7. Eskimo
8. The Blower's Daughter
9. The Girl Who Does Yoga
10. Then Go
11. Volcano
12. Be My Husband
13. Cheers Darlin'

06/05/2003 - Tin Angel, Philadelphia, USA

Setlist
1- Volcano
2- Sand
3- Cold Water
4- The Professor & La Fille Danse
5- Cannonball
6- Fool
7- Woman Like a Man
8- Amie
9- The Girl Who Does Yoga
10- The Blower's Daughter
11- Cheers Darlin'
12- Face
13- Delicate
14- Eskimo

anyone who has any of these shows and could upload this live version?

borneoman · 01-29-2011, 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aski

i checked out all the set lists at ninecrimes.it, and at these shows Dogs was played, then titled "The Girl Who Does Yoga":

21/02/2003 - Hop & Grape, Manchester, Inghilterra

Setlist
01. The professor
02. Volcano
03. Delicate
04. Lazy situation
05. I remember
06. Amie
07. Woman like a man
08. The girl that does yoga
09. Silent night
10. The blower's daughter >
11. Creep
12. Sand
13. Older chests
14. Cannonball
15. Be my husband
16. Childish
17. Cold water >
18. Hallelujah
19. Eskimo

03/05/2003 - Fez Under Time, New York, USA

Setlist
1. Cannonball
2. I Remember
3. Face
4. Prague
5. Older Chests
6. Delicate
7. Eskimo
8. The Blower's Daughter
9. The Girl Who Does Yoga
10. Then Go
11. Volcano
12. Be My Husband
13. Cheers Darlin'

06/05/2003 - Tin Angel, Philadelphia, USA

Setlist
1- Volcano
2- Sand
3- Cold Water
4- The Professor & La Fille Danse
5- Cannonball
6- Fool
7- Woman Like a Man
8- Amie
9- The Girl Who Does Yoga
10- The Blower's Daughter
11- Cheers Darlin'
12- Face
13- Delicate
14- Eskimo

anyone who has any of these shows and could upload this live version?

In my opinion, it was exactly the same

will try to find & upload, I'm sure I have the CD from when he debuted the song... somewhere...

verenita · 01-29-2011, 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aski

i checked out all the set lists at ninecrimes.it, and at these shows Dogs was played, then titled "The Girl Who Does Yoga":

21/02/2003 - Hop & Grape, Manchester, Inghilterra

Setlist
01. The professor
02. Volcano
03. Delicate
04. Lazy situation
05. I remember
06. Amie
07. Woman like a man
08. The girl that does yoga
09. Silent night
10. The blower's daughter >
11. Creep
12. Sand
13. Older chests
14. Cannonball
15. Be my husband
16. Childish
17. Cold water >
18. Hallelujah
19. Eskimo
anyone who has any of these shows and could upload this live version?

i only have this only but the song is listed as Dogs live... weird. here is it (i hope it works, cause i´m not too good at this

):
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=WWYXF1EE

aski · 01-29-2011, 03:59 PM

thank you so much!

downloading now, will check out if it's radically different from the studio or not.

borneoman · 01-30-2011, 08:52 AM

did a search on my compu, and the one I have is the same that Vere posted, first ever Dogs... not that different apart from those parts whent he lyrics were later changed

aski · 01-30-2011, 10:48 AM

i agree, this first live version was not notably different from the studio version.

the only time i heard louder guitar playing on the live version was at the bridge ("And she's always dressed in white"), but overall it was still very similar to the studio version.

verenita · 01-30-2011, 02:34 PM

i also hava a version named "the girl that does yoga", but it´s in my misc folder, so i don´t know when nor where he sang it. it´s quite similar to the manchester version, excpet for the bridge, when he sings "leaves me standing still"... and he says "this doesn´t have a name yet" (or so).
here it is:
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=NMGRF9XE

i love the "and she moves like a little girl, i become a child man, she moves my world" line...

aski · 01-30-2011, 06:32 PM

thank you for this other version, very humbling to know people are so devoted and willing to help me out!

verenita · 01-30-2011, 06:59 PM

well... i don´t own a huge collection, but most of the stuff i have it´s because of eskimo friends generosity

so, now i´m a very happy for having the chance to bring something out. cheers!

01-28-2011, 09:15 PM	#1
aski Eskimo Friend Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Norway Posts: 44	original live version of Dogs? hi! does anyone have the 'original live version' of Dogs from way back before 9 was released? according to the user "mestonf", he really favoured this version instead of the studio version: "All of them are bloody awesome. Though, in comparison to the original live version of 'the girl who does yoga,' I think the studio version is less intensive. What made the live version was his fast guitar strumming. It just doesn't seem to have the same effect on me. Nevertheless, it's just amazing.................absolutely love it!" the user "mestonf" hasn't been online at the forum since 2009, so i guess it would be pointless to ask him about this version. anyone who knows which show this first version appeared at? __________________ "to burn at a slow tempo, that's everything" - Jeff Buckley

01-29-2011, 12:16 AM	#2
verenita ... trusty and true ... Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Argentina Posts: 6,387	i´m a bit lost... i don´t know what "original" live version is, but i´m sure some eskimos mye help you (or even meself if i get an answer ). __________________ ["Read me your favourite line": "No podía sucederme nada peor –pensaba aquel amigo–: tengo el alma delicada."]

01-29-2011, 05:57 AM	#3
aski Eskimo Friend Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Norway Posts: 44	i checked out all the set lists at ninecrimes.it, and at these shows Dogs was played, then titled "The Girl Who Does Yoga": 21/02/2003 - Hop & Grape, Manchester, Inghilterra Setlist 01. The professor 02. Volcano 03. Delicate 04. Lazy situation 05. I remember 06. Amie 07. Woman like a man 08. The girl that does yoga 09. Silent night 10. The blower's daughter > 11. Creep 12. Sand 13. Older chests 14. Cannonball 15. Be my husband 16. Childish 17. Cold water > 18. Hallelujah 19. Eskimo 03/05/2003 - Fez Under Time, New York, USA Setlist 1. Cannonball 2. I Remember 3. Face 4. Prague 5. Older Chests 6. Delicate 7. Eskimo 8. The Blower's Daughter 9. The Girl Who Does Yoga 10. Then Go 11. Volcano 12. Be My Husband 13. Cheers Darlin' 06/05/2003 - Tin Angel, Philadelphia, USA Setlist 1- Volcano 2- Sand 3- Cold Water 4- The Professor & La Fille Danse 5- Cannonball 6- Fool 7- Woman Like a Man 8- Amie 9- The Girl Who Does Yoga 10- The Blower's Daughter 11- Cheers Darlin' 12- Face 13- Delicate 14- Eskimo anyone who has any of these shows and could upload this live version? __________________ "to burn at a slow tempo, that's everything" - Jeff Buckley Last edited by aski; 01-29-2011 at 06:05 AM.

01-29-2011, 03:59 PM	#6
aski Eskimo Friend Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Norway Posts: 44	thank you so much! downloading now, will check out if it's radically different from the studio or not. __________________ "to burn at a slow tempo, that's everything" - Jeff Buckley

01-30-2011, 08:52 AM	#7
borneoman Insane Eskimo Join Date: Jun 2006 Posts: 6,151	did a search on my compu, and the one I have is the same that Vere posted, first ever Dogs... not that different apart from those parts whent he lyrics were later changed __________________ I made you laugh, I made you cry, I made you open up your eyes, didn't I?

01-30-2011, 10:48 AM	#8
aski Eskimo Friend Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Norway Posts: 44	i agree, this first live version was not notably different from the studio version. the only time i heard louder guitar playing on the live version was at the bridge ("And she's always dressed in white"), but overall it was still very similar to the studio version. __________________ "to burn at a slow tempo, that's everything" - Jeff Buckley

01-30-2011, 02:34 PM	#9
verenita ... trusty and true ... Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Argentina Posts: 6,387	i also hava a version named "the girl that does yoga", but it´s in my misc folder, so i don´t know when nor where he sang it. it´s quite similar to the manchester version, excpet for the bridge, when he sings "leaves me standing still"... and he says "this doesn´t have a name yet" (or so). here it is: http://www.megaupload.com/?d=NMGRF9XE i love the "and she moves like a little girl, i become a child man, she moves my world" line... __________________ ["Read me your favourite line": "No podía sucederme nada peor –pensaba aquel amigo–: tengo el alma delicada."]

01-30-2011, 06:32 PM	#10
aski Eskimo Friend Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Norway Posts: 44	thank you for this other version, very humbling to know people are so devoted and willing to help me out! __________________ "to burn at a slow tempo, that's everything" - Jeff Buckley

01-30-2011, 06:59 PM	#11
verenita ... trusty and true ... Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Argentina Posts: 6,387	well... i don´t own a huge collection, but most of the stuff i have it´s because of eskimo friends generosity so, now i´m a very happy for having the chance to bring something out. cheers! __________________ ["Read me your favourite line": "No podía sucederme nada peor –pensaba aquel amigo–: tengo el alma delicada."]